Page 29 - Pure Life 24
P. 29

(


                   /
               28  International Multi. J. of PURE LIFE. 7 (24): 13-37, Autumn 2020

                 In  contrast,  phrases  from            -  True  Unity  and  Plurality
               Christ are quoted that carry the             of Mental: This possibility
               “Trinity”;  that  Christ  said  to           is compatible with monotheism;
               His apostles at the end of His               But  Christians  do  not
               life: I have been given all the              accept it.
               powers of heaven and earth, so            -  True Plurality and Mental
               go  and  make  all  nations  my              Unity:  This  possibility
               disciples  and  Baptize  them  in            requires polytheism.
               the  name  of  “Father”,  “Son”           -  Both True Plurality and
               and  “Holy  Spirit”  and  teach              True Unity; This assumption
               new  disciples  to  obey  all  the           requires  contradiction,
               commands  I  have  given  you.               because  the  concept  of
               Rest assured, wherever you go,               unity  and  plurality  are
               I  am  always  with  you.                    two contradictory concepts,
               (Matthew, 28: 18-20)                         and  the  combination  of
                 Sentences such as “I and the               the  two  in  a  single
               Father are one”, and the Father              instance  is  impossible
               is in me, and I in the Father”,              considering the conditions
               (John, 10: 22 and 40; Ibid, 14: 3)           of contradiction.
               and what is said in the “Gospel         As  Allameh  Tabatabai  has
               of  John”  is  a  proof  for  those   pointed  out,  the  combination
               who  believe  in  the  “Trinity”,     of true unity and true plurality
               and that there are three witnesses    is  impossible  if  the  gender  of
               in  heaven  who  testify:  The        plurality and unity is the same
               Father,  the  Son,  and  the  Holy    and, for example, both types of
               Spirit are one. (John, 5: 7)
                                                     unity  are  personal  or  type  or
                                                     gender.  (Tabatabai,  2006,
               Problems of the “Trinity”
                    1. Opposing  the  Rule  of       Vol. 14: 35)
                       Reason                          In  other  words,  if  the
               In  a  general  classification,       believers in the “Trinity” were
                                                     present to consider the oneness
               three assumptions can be made         of  God  as  figurative  and  to
               for the “Trinity”:
   24   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34