Page 60 - Pure Life 37
P. 60

Personal Identity in… Sh. Vahidi Mehrajardi et al (59

                       two  individuals  would  be               brain,  which  are  influenced

                       distinct  and  not  identical.            by nourishment. However, we
                       Their personalities, identities,          can be certain that the identity
                       emotions,  and  beliefs  would            of  an  individual  remains

                       diverge.  Hence,  they  are               constant,  and  this  can  be
                       unequivocally separate entities.          attributed  to  the  soul,  which
                         Despite creating an identical           remains  alive,  unchangeable,

                       human  being  using  the  same            and immortal  in the  presence
                       materials, it is still impossible         of God.
                       to consider them as being the                This  approach  can  solve
                       same.  This  is  because  every           other  relative  questions  like:

                       entity    consists     of     two         How  do  we  find  out  who  is
                       components:  material  and                who? What evidence bears on
                       form;  While  the  material               the  question  of  whether  the

                       possesses potentiality, it is the         person  here  now  is  the  one
                       form that ultimately determines           who was here yesterday?
                       the  nature  of  the  entity.  The           Numerous  endeavors  have

                       form  activates  the  material,           been      made      in    Western
                       and  merely  repeating  the               philosophy  to  address  these
                       same  form  with  the  same               inquiries. One approach suggests

                       material  is  insufficient  to            that  the  persistence  of  a
                       prove equality. Consequently,             person      can    be    resolved
                       the belief is that the soul must          through  first-person  memory.

                       persist and return to the body            According  to  this  viewpoint,
                       to  maintain the same  identity           if  an  individual  remembers
                       as an individual.                         performing  a  specific  action

                         The  evidence  supporting               or  appears  to  remember,  and
                       this notion lies in the fact that         there     is    evidence       that
                       all  cells  within  the  body             someone  did  it,  this  provides
                       change throughout one's lifetime,         support for the claim that the

                       including  the  cells  in  the
   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65